Dancing around the issueGEORGE WEIGEL
As the Roberts hearings vividly demonstrated, and as any confirmation hearing between now and January 2009 will similarly demonstrate, Roe vs. Wade did not settle the abortion debate.
The American people declining to be so instructed, the debate has not only continued but intensified, even as the federal judiciary's contortions over Roe have continued to distort our law and warp three-plus decades of American politics.
At his hearings, and irrespective of whether John Roberts was being quizzed on a constitutional "right to privacy," his views of judicial precedent, or his philosophy of judging, Roe was lurking just beneath the surface. Some senators looked for clues that a Roberts Court would reverse what Justice Byron White (a Kennedy Democrat) called in 1973 an exercise in "raw judicial power." Others sought assurance that a Roberts Court would do no such thing.
But whatever the euphemisms, it was Roe that was on everyone's mind. Future nominees can expect more of the same.
The arguments and the surrogate-arguments and the pseudo-arguments about Roe have been recycled so many times that it seemed, these past several months, as if there were nothing new to say on the subject (or, in the case of Senator Joe Biden, try to say in correct English). Shortly after Chief Justice Roberts was confirmed, though, a friend sent me the following from Signposts in a Strange Land, a collection of novelist Walker Percy's occasional essays which, if it doesn't say anything precisely new, does put the old truths in a new light, thanks to Percy's keen eye and mordant wit:
"There is a wonderful irony here. It is this: the onset of individual life is not a dogma of the Church but a fact of science. How much more convenient if we lived in the thirteenth century, when no one knew anything about microbiology and arguments about the onset of life were legitimate. Compared to a modern textbook of embryology, Thomas Aquinas sounds like an American Civil Liberties Union member. Nowadays it is not some misguided ecclesiastics who are trying to suppress an embarrassing scientific fact. It is the secular juridical-journalistic establishment.The dance around Roe will continue, because the politics of the moment do not permit an honest confrontation with the facts: the biological facts, the constitutional facts, and the moral facts.
Perhaps, when the dance finally ends, Roe's implausibility as constitutional doctrine will bring it down. Perhaps a Roberts Court, affirming the work of state legislatures on partial-birth abortion, clinic regulation, informed consent and parental notification, will hollow-out the "abortion liberty" to the point where it comes to mean virtually nothing. Perhaps.
Whatever the ultimate judicial outcome, the task of pro-life American citizens will remain the same: to remind our fellow-citizens, our legislators, our governors, our president, and our courts of the facts of the matter. The scientific fact is that a unique human life exits from the moment of conception. The constitutional fact is that Roe was wrongly decided. The moral fact is that the willful taking of an innocent human life is always a grave evil. These are the facts.
Those who deny the facts must be told what they are doing.
George Weigel " Dancing around the issue." The Catholic Difference (October 28, 2005).
Reprinted with permission of George Weigel. George Weigel is the author, most recently, of God's Choice: Pope Benedict XVI and the Future of the Catholic Church, published by HarperCollins.
George Weigel's major study of the life, thought, and action of Pope John Paul II, Witness to Hope: The Biography of Pope John Paul II (Harper Collins, 1999) was published to international acclaim in 1999, and translated into French, Italian, Spanish, Polish, Portuguese, Slovak, Czech, Slovenian, Russian, and German. The 2001 documentary film based on the book won numerous prizes. George Weigel is a consultant on Vatican affairs for NBC News, and his weekly column, "The Catholic Difference," is syndicated to more than fifty newspapers around the United States.
Copyright © 2005 George
Not all articles published on CERC are the objects of official Church teaching, but these are supplied to provide supplementary information.